Fluffernutter Cookie
Meet the cookie that tastes like childhood nostalgia turned all the way up. Our Fluffernutter Cookie is a thick, bakery-style peanut butter cookie stuffed with a creamy marshmallow center, peanut butter chips, white chocolate and finished with golden cookie crumble for that soft, gooey bite everyone is obsessed with.
It’s sweet, nutty, fluffy, and perfectly over-the-top in the best way — the kind of cookie that feels like a peanut butter sandwich, a marshmallow treat, and a bakery dessert all in one.
Perfect for peanut butter lovers, cookie box add-ons, gift boxes, or anyone who loves a soft stuffed cookie with a little crunch.
Flavor notes: peanut butter, marshmallow cream, buttery cookie dough, golden cookie crumble
Texture: thick, soft, gooey, creamy, slightly crunchy
Best enjoyed: room temp or warmed for 8–10 seconds
Allergen notice: Contains wheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, and may contain or come in contact with tree nuts, soy, and other allergens.
Choose shipping or your local pickup day before adding to your box. Local pickup is available Fridays and Saturdays only.
